Megan Erickson Andrew Sullivan has a post where he argues that the economic success of Asians in the United States suggests that the lack of financial success of other groups cannot be chalked up to racism. One response to this kind of argument is that, as a historical matter, anti-Asian racism did hold Asians back and Asians only began to succeed when that racism receded for a number of badly motivated reasons see Ellen Wu.
Printer-Friendly Version In a lot of ways, Asian Americans have done remarkably well in achieving "the American dream" of getting a good education, working at a good job, and earning a good living. So much so that the image many have of Asian Americans is that we are the "model minority" -- a bright, shining example of hard work and patience whose example other minority groups should follow.
However, the practical reality is slightly more complicated than that. Once in a great while, statistics don't lie. It is true that in many ways, Asian Americans have done very well socially and economically. Once the table appears, you can click on a column heading to sort up or down. You can also read the detailed description of the methodology and terminology used to create the statistics.
Yes, in these categories, Asians even outperform Whites. Asian Americans seem to have done so well that magazines such as Newsweek and respected television shows such as 60 Minutes proclaim us to be the "model minority. Many people go even further and argue that since Asian Americans are doing so well, we no longer experience any discrimination and that Asian Americans no longer need public services such as bilingual education, government documents in multiple languages, and welfare.
Further, using the first stereotype of Asian Americans, many just assume that all Asian Americans are successful and that none of us are struggling.
On the surface, it may sound rather benign and even flattering to be described in those terms. However, we need to take a much closer look at these numbers. As we will see, many other statistics show that Asian Americans are still the targets of racial inequality and institutional discrimination and that the model minority image is a myth.
For every Chinese American or South Asian who has a college degree, the same number of Southeast Asians are still struggling to adapt to their lives in the U. The results show that as a whole Asian American families have higher median incomes than White families.
However, this is because in most cases, the typical Asian American family tends to have more members who are working than the typical White family. It's not unusual for an Asian American family to have four, five, or more members working.
A more telling statistic is median personal income also known as per capita income. The results above show that Asian Americans still trail Whites on this very important measure. Case in point, another reason why Asian American families tend to make more than White families is because, as described in the Population Statistics page, Asian Americans are much more likely to concentrate in metropolitan areas where the cost of living is much higher.
Anyone who has lived in New York City yours truly included can attest to just how expensive it is to live in these cities. Therefore, Asian Americans may earn more but they also have to spend more to survive.
In fact, research shows that within these metropolitan areas, Asian American incomes still trail that of Whites.
An Interpretive History by Sucheng Chan. What this means is that basically, a typical Asian American has to get more years of education just to make the same amount of money that a typical White makes with less education.
Recent research from scholars such as Timothy Fong, Roderick Harrison, and Paul Ong, to name just a few, continues to confirm these findings that controlling for other variables, Asian Americans still earn less money than Whites with virtually equal qualifications.Why Asian-Americans Are Not a Model Minority.
On January 9, , sociology professor William Petersen published the highly influential essay. Essay Asian American And Asian Americans. the model minority stereotype, Asian Americans appear to be the “most highly educated of all groups, including white males” (Woo ).
Asian Americans as the Model Minority. that go unnoticed because of the widespread acceptance of Asians as the model minority. version of this essay. By labeling Asian Americans as the model minority, there are many negative consequences for all minority groups in the U.S.
The model minority label generates negative stereotypes for Asian and non-Asians that put these groups at a disadvantage.
More Essay Examples on Asian American Rubric. The classic definition of immigrants refers to a group of people that leaves the land of their birth to establish a new life in a new land - Asians as a Model Minority in the United States Essay introduction.
The term “uprooted” is often associated with immigrants to refer to the symbolic pulling of roots from the native land to hopefully take.
Asian Poverty and the “Model Minority” By Matt Bruenig. Treating Asians in the US as a wealthy monolith papers over their wildly divergent economic situations. A worker in Chinatown in New York City. Jorge Quinteros / Flickr. Our new issue hits the printer this week.